I love lists. Any website that promises to show "The Top X Best Y of ALL TIME" is alright in my book. However it is frequently an exercise in disappointment. Here are the three biggest problems I see with "All Time Best" lists.
Data Sets
If you asked me to choose the "Top 3 Best Major-Release Comedies of 1995" I could do a fair job at that (1. Tommy Boy, 2. Billy Madison, 3. Judge Dredd). This list has a very limited data set; comedies released in 1995 that I actually liked.
Most lists on the Internet have massive data sets which make them wildly subjective and frequently inaccurate. Here are a few "number ones" I pulled from some Google searches:
Best Album of All Time: Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (link)
Best Song of All Time: Like a Rolling Stone (link)
Best Movie of All Time (Tie): The Godfather/The Shawshank Redemption (link)
Best Athlete of All Time: Michael Johnson (link)
Best Car of All Time: McLaren F1 (link)
Best Tech Product of All Time: Netscape Navigator (link)
Many of these lists add explanations (i.e. excuses) why they chose a particular item for number one. The truth is that they could have easily made Imagine (#3) the number one song instead of Like a Rolling Stone with a slick excuse. Personally I am not a fan of any of the songs on this list until you reach #7, Johnny B. Goode.
And how much better is the #1 than the #2 really?
Margins
The inherent problem with large data sets is that the number 1 item is frequently only marginally better than the number 2 item. In fact, the number 1 item might only be marginally better than the number 50 item if there is a huge data set.
For the sake of arguments let's say Rolling Stone had 10,000 albums to choose from for their Top 500 Albums list. The best album would receive the maximum score of 100% and the worst album would receive the minimum score of 0%. If there was an even margin of goodness between each album (.01%) then Like a Rolling Stone is only .06% better than Johnny B. Goode. That is a pretty insignificant difference. In fact, the difference is statistically irrelevant.
What I would really like to see is a list that takes into account the entire data set, assigns a percentage rank to each item, and then shows the best (100%), a pretty good one (80%), an average one (50%), and then the worst one (0%). Then you would see some real differences. I have always wanted to see a full-tackle football game between the Chargers and a local JV high school team.
Good vs. Important
Is a top-ranked list item actually good or is it just important? Ginette and I both watched Blade Runner for a cinematography class at UCSD. While I can appreciate the influences of this movie, the film noir homage, the brilliance of Philip K. Dick's original work, the swaggering charm of Harrison Ford, and the future career of Ridley Scott, I really don't like this movie. It is dull and I feel like have seen the same thing a dozen times. Perhaps if i watched it when it first came out (I was 2 years old) I would feel differently. I also didn't like The Godfather and A Streetcar Named Desire. Sacrilegious I know.
My point.
On my desk I have a copy of Cryptonomicon by Neal Stephenson. It is a daunting 1152 pages. I bought it based on a Top 100 Sci-Fi Books list I Googled the other day. It was the highest ranked book on the list that was written recently (1999) by an author I had heard of (I read Snow Crash). By my logic, this will be a good book, not simply an important one. However, 1152 pages is a much larger commitment than a 3 minute song so I am worried.
I'll start it tomorrow.
Thursday, May 10, 2007
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
Google Maps

So everyone knows Google Maps is the greatest (Tru dat! Double True!). However, they really solidified their position on the top with this new My Maps feature. I am having way too much fun with it.
Stalkers pay attention: Here are a few of the maps I have created.
Upcoming Seattle Trip
Favorite Restaurants in San Diego
Walking Direction to my Apartment
Bike Trail
Saturday, March 31, 2007
Friday, March 23, 2007
F.E.A.R.
I am having a great time discovering all my PC games again now that I ponied up and bought a decent video card. With my old viseo card Half-Life 2 and World of Warcraft always ran pretty well but I had to adjust Oblivion and F.E.A.R. down to 640x480 with all the pretty settings turned down to get any sort of decent frame rate.
This may sound cliché but playing a PC game the way developers intended is really the only way to go. It is truly a different experience. Playing some of these games has more in common with watching a movie than playing OG Super Mario Bros. While Mario was a ton of fun there was no doubt that you were playing a game that existed outside of yourself. The immersive experience of playing F.E.A.R. has the same hypnotic qualities of going to a movie. I find myself playing the same section of the game over and over just to see what it looks like to kill people from different angles and with different weapons. It's like watching the Matrix lobby scene but choosing to have Neo bust through the metal detector with a bucket full of grenades instead of a coat full of guns.
This may sound cliché but playing a PC game the way developers intended is really the only way to go. It is truly a different experience. Playing some of these games has more in common with watching a movie than playing OG Super Mario Bros. While Mario was a ton of fun there was no doubt that you were playing a game that existed outside of yourself. The immersive experience of playing F.E.A.R. has the same hypnotic qualities of going to a movie. I find myself playing the same section of the game over and over just to see what it looks like to kill people from different angles and with different weapons. It's like watching the Matrix lobby scene but choosing to have Neo bust through the metal detector with a bucket full of grenades instead of a coat full of guns.
Friday, March 16, 2007
I'm a Star
Back in junior high I had a very small role as a young Tex Watson for a film created by Biola University. My family kept a copy on VHS but I haven't seen it in years. Just today my Dad sent me a link Tex Watson's ministry website, Abounding Love, which posted the movie in its entirety (about 35 minutes). My 30 seconds of screen time appear in the first couple of minutes. Make sure to keep watching past the first interview scene in prison to catch a bonus shot of my Dad as an extra in the church scene wearing a bolo tie. The movie is based on a very interesting story that is worth reading about. However the budget was, clearly, very low. I think they spent all their money on fake mustache rentals. =)Video Link: http://www.aboundinglove.org/media/index.php
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)